Nie wenjuan, Yang pinghua, Chen yunbo, et al. A comparative study on three different diagnostic procedures for wide QRS complex tachycardia[J]. 2021, (2): 95-99.
Nie wenjuan, Yang pinghua, Chen yunbo, et al. A comparative study on three different diagnostic procedures for wide QRS complex tachycardia[J]. 2021, (2): 95-99.DOI:
LLA的Kappa值为0.662。结论 a VR单导联四步法的准确性及敏感度高于LLA及室速积分法。LLA的约登指数高于a VR单导联四步法及室速积分法。LLA与室速积分法的特异度一致
高于a VR单导联四步法。两位医师诊断结果一致性较好的是LLA
其次为a VR单导联四步法
最差的为室速积分法。三种鉴别流程各有优缺点
在临床实践中可扬长避短
综合运用。
Abstract
Objective To investigate the clinical value of three ECG algorithms for the differentiation diagnosis of wide QRS complex tachycardia(WCT). These three algorithms included a VR single lead four step method(short named as a VR-lead method)
ventricular tachycardia score(short named as VT-score method) and limb lead algorithm(LLA). Methods Twelve-lead electrocardiogram(ECG) was selected from 41 patients with WCT. The nature of the tachycardia was confirmed by intracardiac electrophysiology. The diagnosis was made by two experts in ECG diagnosis using these three diagnostic procedures. The sensitivity
specificity
accuracy
Youden index and consistency of the three methods were compared. Results The accuracy of the a VR-lead method
the VT-score method
and the LLA in the diagnosis of VT was 80.5%
48.8%
and 78.1%. The sensitivity was 87.9%
42.4%
and78.8%; the specificity was 50.0%
75.0%
and 75.0%; and the Youden index was 37.89%
17.4%
and 53.8%. The kappa value of the a VR-lead method
VT-score method
and LLA was 0.485
0.015
and 0.662
respectively.Conclusions The accuracy and sensitivity of a VR-lead method were higher than those of LLA and VT-score method.The Youden index of LLA was higher than those of a VR-lead method and VT-score method. The specificity of LLA was consistent with that of VT-score method
which was higher than that of a VR-lead method. Between the two experts
LLA was the most consistent
followed by a VR-lead method
and then the VT-score method. The three identification methods have their own advantages and disadvantages